Let her think she's the first one
When a chick starts the foreplay placing her hand on your thigh and shamelessly touching your cock through the jeans you know this date has a chance to be special. Fuck reading the book when she signals she's ready for anal sex and this guy got it all right slowly working his erect cock down his girlfriend's tight chocolate hole after she gave him an absolutely fantastic blowjob. It was even better than he could hope for, the best ass he's ever fucked, but she'll never know that cuz he told her she was the first one he tried anal sex with. Naive slut!